The Watkinsville City Council on Wednesday evening tabled a proposal from Mayor Brian Brodrick to spend $75,000 on a traffic study, opting instead to wait until the city has additional information on the study being conducted and funded by Oconee County.
Brodrick argued that the city does not know the outcome of the study commissioned by the Oconee County Board of Commissioners, but that he anticipated “they're going to have a very different perspective on what's important to Watkinsville than we do.”
Both the county’s study, which is underway, and the study requested by Brodrick are in response to the proposal by the Georgia Department of Transportation (GDOT) to build a truck bypass along one of three alternate routes south of Watkinsville connecting SR 15 with U.S. 441.
Council Member Jeff Campbell was most outspoken in opposition to taking action at this point, saying it made more sense to him to wait until the county study was completed before spending city money on an independent study.
Council Member Christine Tucker argued that the proposed study would not duplicate the county’s work already underway and that, as discussions with the county begin, the Council needs data that represent “the perspective of the citizens of Watkinsville.”
When Council Members Brett Thomas and Connie Massie sided with Campbell, as did two of the three citizens who spoke, Brodrick called for a motion to table his request until the next meeting of Council. That motion passed unanimously.
Oconee County Board of Commissioners Chair John Daniell said on Wednesday morning that traffic counts were taken last week and that WSP, the firm with whom the county has contracted for its study, will spend the next weeks reviewing the data collected.
On Wednesday afternoon a group of at least a half dozen Oconee County residents representing the Save South Oconee group turned out at the state Transportation Board meeting in Athens with signs protesting the proposed truck bypass south of Watkinsville. They were not given a chance to speak to the Board.
Oconee County Commission Study
The Oconee County Board of Commissioners on Oct. 6 approved a $275,000 contract with WSP, an international professional services company with offices in Kennesaw, for a traffic study of downtown Watkinsville.
Included will be the collection of data on traffic corridors and congestion in the city, encompassing average daily traffic and turning movement counts at key intersections, vehicle classifications, and crash patterns.
The WSP study will include “but not be limited to” the bypass routes linking SR 15 and U.S. 441 south of Watkinsville proposed by consultants for GDOT.
WSP will assess alternative intersection configurations, which may include roundabouts and one-way traffic patterns.
As the final product, WSP will identify and evaluate “roadway layout alternatives” and estimate costs for those alternatives.
Daniell said in an email message on Wednesday (Nov. 18) morning that “Traffic count map locations were shared with Watkinsville, and the data collected will be available” to the city.
Brodrick’s Proposal
City Manager Sharyn Dickerson told Council at the meeting on Wednesday evening that “We're asking tonight for approval of an agreement with Galloway and Company to conduct a comprehensive traffic circulation study of the Main Street corridor.”
![]() |
| Brodrick 11/18/2026 |
The Professional Services Agreement presented to Council from Galloway, at Atlanta firm, outlined “a scope of services to develop traffic forecasts and intersection capacity analyses to understand existing and potential future scenarios to assist the City in developing its own recommendations for roadway improvements to serve local traffic and to better compare against those prepared by the County’s consultant.”
“The mayor did offer for the city to participate in the county study,” Dickerson said, “but the county decided to proceed without our participation.”
Board of Commissioners Chair John Daniell said at the Commission meeting on Oct. 6 “We were working on a joint meeting with the city. We were hopeful to do that on the 5th of this month. But getting everybody's schedules lined up did not prove as easy as one might think.”
“However, we we're still hoping to having a joint meeting that may come to pass here in the next couple months,” he said, “but as time is of the essence I recommend we move forward with the WSP proposal as presented tonight.”
“We do have funds set aside right now that would pay for this study,” Brodrick said on Wednesday when Dickerson had finished.
“I think the good thing about this is it would give us an opportunity to truly partner with the county,” he continued. “We don't know what's going to come out in their study.”
“But they're going to have a very different perspective on what's important to Watkinsville than we do, and we're ultimately the voice of the citizens and the city,” he said.
“You know, when we didn't really have the opportunity to participate with the county,” Brodrock said. “I think it's important that we have the opportunity to do” the Galloway study.
Campbell and Tucker Exchange
“My preference would be to hear the county’s report,” Campbell said as soon as Dickerson and Brodrick had finished.
“And then take that data and see if we need to do our own study,” he said. “It may or may not address everything that we would like to see done. but I'd rather have that information.”
![]() |
| Campbell 11/18/2026 |
“Then we can decide whether or not we want to spend money on doing this type of study,” he said.
“One of the things I like about this proposal is we're not duplicating things,” Tucker said. “It's not like we're going out and doing the same thing.”
“It sounds like we know what the county is studying, or at least the data they're collecting,” she continued. “And so we're not duplicating that.”
“I just think as a conversation starts with the county, it's important to have the perspective of the citizens of Watkinsville from the get go, and let's not be starting from behind.”
“I don't love spending money,” she said. “I mean I'm frugal, but I also think that sometimes it is important to spend a little bit of money in order to get what we need for our citizens.”
“I am interested in finding out how long it's going to take for the county to get theirs done,” Thomas said when asked by Brodrick for his reaction.
“I agree with Jeff, and I think we should get the report, look at it, see if we have any thoughts to go along with it or change it or whatever,” Massey said.
Council Member Chuck Garrett was not present due to illness.
Citizen Comment, Brodrick Response
“I think we should speak to the county,” Kathleen McQuiston said, when citizens were given the chance to come to the podium to speak. “Find out how long their study is going to take. Table this for a month or two. And then take it up again.”
![]() |
| Tucker 11/18/2026 |
“I think be best just to wait until you get one back from the county,” Jason Smith said, referring to the study the county is undertaking. “And if you feel like you need to spend that time doing something constructive, I would to work on my relationship with the county.”
McQuiston and Smith were the first and third citizen to speak.
“Who are you all speaking to with the county commissioners that are not talking back,” Alan Bell asked Brodrick, when he went to the podium ahead of Smith.
“Because we're hearing the exact same thing. That you guys are not willing to work with them,” Bell said.
“What we offered when we found out they were doing a study,” Brodrick responded, “is that we would like to partner with them and we've said all along we'd like to partner with them.”
“So we offered to pay for half of the study, and for us to do that study jointly so that way we would both have equal footing in terms of how that was done,” Brodrick continued. “The county also had asked us to commit to funding millions of dollars of downtown traffic improvement as a part of that.”
“And we felt like before TSPLOST passed, we would be unable to commit to funding millions of dollars of traffic improvements downtown,” Brodrick said. “And so we were unable to schedule a meeting with them. We still wouldn't mind scheduling a meeting with them.”
Voters turned down renewal of the Transportation Special Purpose Local Option Sales Tax (TSPLOST) on Nov. 3. Watkinsville would have received $5.5 million as its share of those revenues had it passed.”
Brodrick’s Continued Response To Bell
“We can't commit to funding millions of dollars of downtown traffic improvements as the senior partner, not the junior partner in that arrangement, without us having any idea of what is going to be proposed and having a voice in the study,” Brodrick told Bell. “And without knowing if TSPLOST was going to pass because we don't have the money to do that.”
“So the response at that point was, well, we're going to go our own way and we're going to do this,” Brodrick said. “So we have conversations. It's not like we don't want to cooperate. We're going to let them use our data and they're going to use ours.”
“But we also feel like we need to have our own study, that we would want something that really reflects the broader planning perspective of Watkinsville,” he continued. “And at this point, I don't have any indication that that's what WSP is going to engage in.”
“So it's not like there's a bad relationship,” Brodrick said. “We've been very transparent with the county and they've been transparent with us about what we're doing.”
“But we also feel like we have a different, very different point of view that's oriented in community health and not just how do we move traffic through Watkinsville as fast as possible” he said. “So that's the balance that we're trying to find out.”
Daniell’s Response
I sent Daniell an email message on Thursday (Nov. 19) morning repeating Brodrick’s statement that Watkinsville “offered to pay for half of the study” the county was undertaking and that the county “had asked us to commit to funding millions of dollars of downtown traffic improvement as a part of that.”
Daniell provided an email message he received from Brodrick dated Oct. 2 in which Brodrick wrote that “The city council would like to split the cost of the study and be full partners in it with the county.”
![]() |
| Daniell 10/26/2026 |
Brodrick also wrote that “I regret that the potential Oct. 5 joint meeting time did not work for us.”
Daniell sent an email response to Brodrick dated Oct. 3 in which Daniell said “The Board of Commissioners feels time is of the essence to respond to our citizens expectations on this matter...We are willing to meet at a future date that aligns with the council.”
With that email of Oct. 3, Daniell wrote: “Based on comments received, I am attaching an update agreement for everyone to review along with the WSP proposal.”
The attached Intergovernmental Agreement (IGA), which Daniell provided me late on Thursday (Nov. 19), said the county would enter into an agreement with WSP, with the costs shared equally by the county and the city.
“Within 45 days of the completion of the Study, the County and City will individually adopt the findings of the Study in an open meeting,” the agreement states. “Failure of either party to adopt the findings will terminate the agreement without penalty.”
“Within three months of the adoption of the Study, the County and City shall mutually develop plans for implementing the recommendations of the Study,” according to the agreement, with the county committing to fund $1.6 million and the city committing to spending $4 million.
Additional spending beyond that level would be split with the city paying 60 percent and the county 40 percent, according to the agreement.
Additional Comment From Daniell
“We got a scope and pricing from WSP, a proven service provider for the County and City,” Daniell said in an email message to me that followed copies of his correspondence with Brodrick.
“The scope, pricing and a draft IGA were provided to the City,” Daniell wrote.
“The Mayor and I could not reach consensus on the IGA,” Daniell said. “I attempted to schedule a joint meeting of the BOC and Council. However, that was not successful. I believed there was still potential for a joint meeting.”
“I advised the Mayor we would be moving forward with WSP as time was of the essence,” he wrote. “The Mayor offered the fund 50 percent of the study. I advised the Mayor no funding was necessary until we finalized the IGA.”
Transportation Board Meeting
Bell, who has been one of the more active members of Save South Oconee, said he had organized a group of about 12 people to attend the Nov. 18 meeting of the state Transportation Board at the Classic Center in Athens. The Board was meeting in Athens rather than Atlanta as part of the statewide Transportation Summit.
![]() |
| Shelby, At Podium Smith With Sign, Gisler On Far Right 11/18/2026 |
I was not able to attend because of a family commitment, but I did watch the meeting as it was being livecast.
As Albert Shelby III, Director of Program Delivery for GDOT, was speaking near the beginning of the meeting, with the camera focused on Shelby, Smith moved into the area behind Shelby and held up a sign that read: “Oconee Does Not Want Your Watkinsville Bypass.”
Standing next to Smith, but without a sign, was State House District 121 Rep. Eric Gisler, who had released a letter from Shelby on Nov. 16 in which Shelby rejecting Gisler’s request that GDOT release data it used in assessing the routes being proposed for the Watkinsville truck bypass.
Gisler said in an email after the Wednesday meeting that he did speak briefly after the meeting with Shelby about the contents of that letter.
Oconee County Commissioner Chuck Horton also attended. Horton said in a telephone conversation on Thursday that his presence was in response to a request from the Save South Oconee group.
Oconee County Commissioner Amrey Harden said in an email message on Thursday that “I was made aware of the meeting by Alan Bell, but I was not able to attend due to another commitment.”
Bell sent me a photo of himself, Smith, and four others talen at the Classic Center with signs protesting the bypass.
![]() |
| Smith, Third From Left, Smith, Far Right 11/18/2026 |
Shortly after Smith appeared behind Shelby with the protest sign, the camera was taken off Shelby, and that camera was not used at any point during the remainder of the 41 minute-long-meeting, though speakers continued to appear at the podium.
Video
The video below is on the Watkinsville web site.
I did attend the Council meeting, and the still images of the Council members above are from video clips I shot.
Discussion of the transportation study begins at 46:06 in the video.
The Transportation Board meeting is below.
Smith and his sign are visible at 9:17 I the video.






No comments:
Post a Comment